How many members did The Sherlock Society have at their meeting in the school library?

How many members did The Sherlock Society have at their meeting in the school library?

• A. Three
• B. Four
• C. Two
• D. Five

Answer: (A)

Counting attendees from a short scene is about combining every clue about who was present with any notes about who wasn’t, and then narrowing to a single total that fits all statements. In this scenario, the clues align so that exactly three members can be identified as being in the school library for the meeting. There isn’t a statement listing a fourth person as present, and there aren’t any indications that would require a different number of attendees. Any other count would contradict one of the details given—either suggesting someone who wasn’t there was present, or conflicting with who was explicitly noted as part of the group. So the only consistent total is three attendees, which is why that option is the best answer. When solving similar questions, it helps to list who is confirmed to be present, note any mentions of who is absent or late, and check which counts would violate those constraints.

Counting attendees from a short scene is about combining every clue about who was present with any notes about who wasn’t, and then narrowing to a single total that fits all statements.

In this scenario, the clues align so that exactly three members can be identified as being in the school library for the meeting. There isn’t a statement listing a fourth person as present, and there aren’t any indications that would require a different number of attendees. Any other count would contradict one of the details given—either suggesting someone who wasn’t there was present, or conflicting with who was explicitly noted as part of the group.

So the only consistent total is three attendees, which is why that option is the best answer. When solving similar questions, it helps to list who is confirmed to be present, note any mentions of who is absent or late, and check which counts would violate those constraints.